Photo by owner, retrieved 9/30/2025

Aroma Pizzeria: A Chicago Staple with Over Two Decades of Flavor

Located at 5350 N Broadway, just south of Catalpa and across from Jewel-Osco in Chicago’s vibrant Edgewater neighborhood, Aroma Pizzeria is a beloved Italian eatery that has been serving the community since 1999. With free parking available next door at Byline Bank (Monday–Friday after 6 PM, Saturday after 1 PM, and all day Sunday) and a charming summer patio for outdoor seating, this local gem combines authentic Italian cuisine with a welcoming, community-focused vibe.

A Rich History of Aroma Pizzeria

Aroma Pizzeria opened its doors in August 1999 as a modest 1,000-square-foot slice-and-carry-out shop on Berwyn Avenue, founded with a mission to provide generous portions of fine-dining quality cuisine at reasonable prices. In 2002, Jim Dababneh, the current proprietor and executive chef, took ownership, bringing his passion for high-quality ingredients and customer satisfaction to the forefront. Under his leadership, Aroma evolved into a full-service restaurant with 56 indoor seats, a quaint full liquor bar, and three big-screen TVs for sports enthusiasts. The addition of a summer patio enhanced its appeal as a go-to spot for al fresco dining in warmer months. Over 25 years later, Aroma remains a neighborhood staple, staying true to its “old school” focus on bold flavors, competent service, and exceptional value.

A Delightful Dining Experience

My first visit to Aroma Pizzeria, after years of intending to stop by, was a revelation. The atmosphere strikes a perfect balance between cozy and lively, ideal for a casual meal or a relaxed evening out. The service was exceptional—our waiter was prompt, courteous, and meticulous, ensuring every need was met with precision.

The menu is a highlight, boasting a wide array of options that cater to diverse tastes. From classic Italian dishes to creative offerings, there’s something for everyone. A standout feature is the variety of French fries and types, including unique Greek-style fries—a rare treat not often found elsewhere. On this visit, a friend and I shared a 14-inch tavern-style pizza, known for its cracker-like, crispy crust. It arrived piping hot, perfectly baked, and bursting with flavor, living up to its reputation for crispiness.

Practical Details

Aroma’s location is highly convenient, situated half a mile from Lake Shore Drive and two blocks from the Berwyn Red Line El Stop. The free parking lot next door at Byline Bank is a rare asset in Chicago, especially when the nearby street parking meter was non-operational during my visit. The summer patio offers a delightful option for outdoor dining, perfect for enjoying Edgewater’s warm evenings. The restaurant is open daily for dine-in, takeout, and delivery, with an integrated online ordering platform and in-house drivers ensuring top-notch service.

Final Thoughts

Aroma Pizzeria exceeded expectations with its delicious food, top-notch service, and inviting atmosphere. Rooted in over 25 years of tradition under Jim Dababneh’s dedicated leadership, yet fresh with menu innovations like Greek-style fries, it’s a true Chicago gem. I’m already eager to return to explore more of the menu, especially those intriguing fries. For anyone seeking authentic Italian cuisine in Edgewater, Aroma Pizzeria is a must-visit.